No Dogs Nor Humans Here

A short story

Photo by Terrye Turpin edited with the Waterlogue app

I couldn’t put it off any longer. I would have to tell him the truth. That morning, while my android assistant, Arnie, ran through his usual cleaning routine, he found the dog toy under the bed. I thought he’d make the connection. Instead, his carefully composed face stayed in the blank configuration that meant he was processing information. Something almost like emotion caused his brow to crease, and I marveled anew at the advances we’d made in artificial intelligence. Intelligence that grew ever closer to human — that dangerous dividing line between flesh and blood and machine.

“Shannon, what should I do with this?” Arnie held out the toy, balanced on his arms like an offering. The dog toy resembled a duck. The original color had been a brilliant crimson. The toy had a flat yellow bill, and two webbed feet stuck out flat behind the body. The dull red terry-cloth surface was stained and torn. Stuffing leaked from a rip near the head.

“I’ll take care of it.” I took the toy from Arnie. “You can finish the vacuuming and we’ll do laundry later. I’d like some exercise. We’ll walk to the store and pick up some things.”

Arnie swiveled and went back to the chore he’d been doing when he discovered the dog toy. If I didn’t look too closely, I could pretend I shared my living space with another human instead of a machine. Except for his gray synthetic skin, Arnie appeared just like any other man. All androids had flesh in odd colors, to tell them apart from their human creators.

At thirty-five, I’d lived alone almost all my adult life. Arnie was enough company for me. He’d never get sick, he never complained, and I didn’t have to feed him. I didn’t even have to share a bed with him — he stayed upright in a charging port at night.

I meant to throw out the dog toy. Halfway to the trash chute, I stopped. I’d gotten rid of all the rest last year — the bowls, collar, leash, bed, toys. How had this strange duck slipped past notice? My hands shook and I couldn’t do it, couldn’t toss this last reminder into the garbage. Instead, I tucked it into the cabinet over the washer. A carton of laundry soap hid the toy from view. I couldn’t throw it out, but I didn’t want to look at it either.

I got Dolly right after college. She was a birthday present from my boyfriend. A squirming ball of white, brown, and tan fur, Dolly was a mutt — a shepherd, collie, who-knows-what mongrel mix. I fell out of love with the boyfriend, and in love with Dolly. He left, but the dog stayed. It was just the two of us for so long, then Arnie joined us five years ago. He was a big help toward the end. Dolly had trouble getting up onto the bed, and Arnie would take her in his arms and gently place her beside me.

“Do we need the cart?” Arnie stood at the hall closet, where we stored the little wheeled cart I used to carry groceries. He opened the door to the closet, prepared to grab the shopping cart.

“No. I’m only picking up some things for dinner. We’re out of onions and tomatoes.”

As Arnie swung the door shut, the hook mounted inside rattled against the wood. I’d hung Dolly’s leash there, before.

The stroll to the store took us past the park. It was a Saturday, and folks enjoying the late summer afternoon filled the green space. There was just enough cool in the air to hint at the promise of autumn. We stopped for a moment to watch a little boy toss a red ball to his dog. The dog, a small black Scottish terrier, had fur that matched the boy’s hair color. The scotty, pink tongue hanging out, weaved and danced through the boy’s legs. The last throw went wild, and the red ball rolled down the slope toward us. It stopped at Arnie’s feet.

“Sorry!” The boy arrived at the same time as his dog. Arnie scooped up the ball and handed it to the boy. “Thank you,” the child said before he scampered back to the park. The scotty lingered a moment longer, and I wondered if Arnie would bend to pet the animal.

I touched his arm. “We should go, get to the store and back before dark.” We left the park, but I caught Arnie glancing behind us to watch the dog.

Later, as I was cleaning the dishes from my dinner, Arnie wandered into the kitchen. He set the dog toy on the counter.

“How did you find this?” I backed away, wiping my soapy hands on a towel. Steeling myself, I picked up the toy. It still smelled faintly of her breath. I brushed a short, white hair into the sink. Arnie must have searched the apartment until he found the toy.

Instead of answering my question, Arnie posed one of his own. “This item must be important?”

“A year ago,” I began, “we had a dog. Dolly. Do you remember?” I handed the cloth duck back to Arnie. He clutched it.

“Like the dog in the park?”

“A dog, yes, but not quite like the little black dog.”

“I can’t.” Arnie shook his head. “Was there something terrible?”

“Dolly lived with us and then she went away.” I couldn’t do this.

“Permission to access my memory backup?”

I nodded. “Yes.” And then I waited while Arnie restored those memories that I’d erased a year ago.

“Oh,” he said.

I saw it then, the emotion that shouldn’t have been there on his smooth, unlined face. He remembered her. “It’s okay.” Silly. Me, trying to comfort a machine. Something that shouldn’t have learned this, that shouldn’t be able to process grief.

“I’m so sorry, Shannon.” Arnie embraced me, and I cried against his shoulder.

I should have removed those memories again. We had all been warned of the danger when artificial learning went too far, became too much like us. Arnie, unlike the children’s story character Pinocchio, would never be allowed to be a real boy.

We wrapped the toy duck in a soft towel and stored it in a cardboard box printed in bright colors. We’d scattered her ashes last year, Arnie and I. Now he remembered that, remembered the good things too. It was a mistake to take that from him the first time, and I’ll not repeat it. We’ll share our joy and our grief and in time these things will make us both a little more human.

THE END

Our Proof of Devotion

Image courtesy of Shutterdemon at FreeDigitalPhotos.net

I am not a dog person. In fact, I think the perfect pet for me might just be a raccoon — one of those animals that are able to open trash cans and get their own dinner. Despite this, I agreed to watch over my friend’s pet while she was out of town for a week. Misty is the kind of friend who doesn’t ask for a favor, instead she presents the thing she wants you to do as a unique opportunity, one you’d be foolish to turn down. She pitched the dog watching as sort of a mini vacation, one in which I would share her apartment space with Clara, a bull dog with body odor and an allergy to grass. I spent the week with the dog because Misty is also the kind of friend who would gladly assist you with digging out a sewer line.

Her work space in the cubicle we share is decorated with an assortment of stuffed bull dogs and pictures of Clara. Here is adorable Clara holding a ball in her mouth, tiny Clara as a puppy under a Christmas tree, and contemplative Clara in sepia, posed in an old fashioned wash tub. How do you tell someone that you don’t care for their dog? It’s like admitting that you don’t like sunshine, or oxygen.

“I want you to come over this evening, so Clara can get used to you”, Misty told me the week before I was scheduled to stay. When I arrived at her apartment, Misty decided that Clara and I needed some alone time together, so my friend left to do some shopping. The dog and I were supposed to play together, to bond, but we wound up spending time doing what I often did with my children when they were young — we watched television. I brushed the dog hair off to clear a spot on the couch, and sat down. Clara settled next to me and fell asleep snoring.

When Misty returned Clara greeted her happily, jumping up and panting. “Did you have a good time?” I started to answer, but then realized that Misty was asking the dog for her opinion.

“Let me show you how to walk her.” My friend brought out a special harness and a retractable leash. The leash was one of those designed to give your animal the illusion of freedom, while guaranteeing that the dog owner will find herself wrapped around a tree or light pole at some point. Attached to the leash was a container that dispensed little bright blue plastic bags. “I want you to watch when Clara poops, that way you’ll know how much to expect, and how to know when she’s finished.” I tried to picture myself staring at the dog’s back end and gauging the size of the deposits while Misty continued talking. “And don’t let her eat any acorns or she’ll upchuck on the carpet, she’s allergic.”

“How many times does she poop?” I asked. There seemed to be an awful lot of those little blue bags loaded in the holder. Misty explained that Clara went at least two or three times during each walk. She offered to let me try the bagging after the first stop, but I told her that I thought I could figure it out later.

“You’ll be walking Clara first thing in the morning, and you’ll need to be home right after work, by six at least, to walk her again. Then wait thirty minutes for her stomach to settle, feed her two cups of food, and walk her once more before bedtime.” A quick calculation on my part estimated that was 16 or 18 little bags a day. I planned on double bagging. “All right, here’s the list of instructions, don’t forget the after dinner treat for her teeth. Her allergy medicine is in the pantry, if she gets in too much grass she’ll start scratching. The medicine knocks her out, so just give it at bedtime. You can sleep in my bed if you want, and Clara will probably sleep with you. If she whines that means she wants under the covers.” As Misty handed me the page filled with notes on the care and feeding of her dog, it occurred to me that I would have gotten off easier taking care of someone’s elderly grandparent or small child.

On our first day of walking I nervously tried to steer Clara away from the acorns that she wanted to slurp up like a furry Hoover. I did allow her to eat all the dried bugs she found, as Misty had not specified that these were forbidden. We stayed on the sidewalk, avoiding the grass until it was time for scooping. I hoped that the dog wouldn’t suffer an allergic reaction, since I couldn’t imagine how I would get her to swallow the sedative. I would have to take one myself first.

The second day of my visit with Clara, she met me at the door, tongue hanging out and what passed for a dog smile on her face. On the third day, I could see her watching me from the front window as I parked my car. Her flat doggie face, pressed to the glass, reminded me of those wives of long ago ship captains, pacing along the widow’s walks and searching for signs of their loved ones to return from the sea.

We passed other dog owners on our evening strolls. They stood and watched their pets drop the by-products of digestion, and then like good citizens they stooped to pick up the mess. We smiled and nodded as we passed, recognizing in each other that common bond — love for family, pets and friends. And waving a happy goodbye, we each went on our own way, carrying the proof of our devotion with us in those little plastic bags.

*This story previously published as “Devotion” in the Texas Writers Journal Q1 January 2014 issue.